Sunday, June 07, 2009

Texas cop Tasers great-grandmother

She must have been very intimidating when she refused to sign a ticket. [Link]

At this point, the stories diverge. According to Precinct 3 Constable Richard McCain, Winkfein cursed and refused to cooperate. She says nothing of the sort occurred. "I wasn't argumentative, I was not combative. This is a lie," the woman told a news reporter for Fox 7.

Either way, it's difficult to see how the issuance of a speeding ticket to an elderly woman devolved to the point where a grown, trained law-enforcement officer could be considered justified in subjecting the speeder to an electric jolt intended to disrupt her nervous system -- no matter what command of profanity she displayed.

Given that the speeding ticket had already been issued, it's also difficult to understand what purpose was served by prolonging the encounter and demanding a signature. A similar incident in Utah in 2007 between a state trooper and a motorist also resulted in a Tasering after the driver declined to sign a speeding ticket. In that case, the officer escalated the matter to a violent conclusion even though Utah law doesn't actually require a signature. Texas law apparently follows the same reasoning, considering the signature merely a promise to appear in court, not a necessity for the validity of the ticket itself.

Thank you officer, for protecting us from dangerous perps like 72 year old great grandmother Kathryn Winkfein. Idiot.

2 comments:

bunny42 said...

If she'd had a pacemaker, she'd be dead now. Excellent common sense. Guys like that give law enforcement a bad name.

Jeff said...

A lot of cops seem to treat tasers as Star Trek phasers set on stun (complete safe).

Post a Comment